Back to Blog
For Family Offices • Operator Selection
Selecting the Right Senior Housing Operator: Family Office Guide
Selecting the right operator is the single most important decision for family offices investing in senior housing. This guide provides a comprehensive framework for evaluating operator track record, operational capabilities, clinical quality, financial stability, and partnership alignment.
16 min read•For Family Offices
What this article explains:
- •Topic: Selecting the right senior housing operator for family office investments
- Who this is for: Family offices, institutional investors, and capital allocators evaluating operator partnerships
- Problems addressed: Operator selection risk, operational underperformance, regulatory failures, and partnership misalignment
- Systems involved: Operator evaluation frameworks, management agreements, NNN leases, and joint venture structures
- Why this matters now: The operator drives 80% of investment performance—selecting the right partner is the most critical decision
Why Operator Selection Matters
In senior housing, the operator drives 80% of investment performance. Real estate location and physical plant matter, but operational execution—staffing, clinical quality, marketing, resident satisfaction—determines occupancy, pricing power, and long-term cash flow.
A great operator can succeed in a B+ location. A poor operator will fail in an A+ location.
Family offices must view operator selection as a multi-year partnership, not a vendor relationship. The operator will make hundreds of daily decisions affecting resident care, staff retention, and financial performance—decisions that directly impact your investment returns.
Operator Evaluation Framework
1. Track Record & Experience
- Years in senior housing: Minimum 10+ years operating assisted living or memory care
- Portfolio size: 5+ properties under management; demonstrates operational scale
- Property type expertise: Direct experience with target property type (AL, MC, IL, SNF)
- Geographic experience: Familiarity with target market and state regulations
- Performance track record: Occupancy trends, NOI growth, property sales history
- Crisis management: How operator performed during COVID-19 pandemic
2. Management Team Quality
- CEO/Founder background: Healthcare experience, operational expertise, industry reputation
- Regional VPs: Span of control (1 VP per 5-8 properties typical); oversight capabilities
- Executive directors: Tenure, licensure, resident satisfaction scores
- Bench strength: Succession planning, internal promotion track record
- Compensation structure: Alignment with performance (occupancy bonuses, NOI targets)
3. Operational Systems & Technology
- Electronic medical records (EMR): Modern EMR system for care documentation, medication administration
- CRM & marketing: Lead tracking, conversion analytics, occupancy forecasting
- Financial reporting: Monthly P&L, occupancy reports, KPI dashboards
- Staffing & scheduling: Workforce management systems, time tracking, labor optimization
- Resident billing: Automated billing, accounts receivable management
4. Clinical Quality & Compliance
- State survey history: Review last 3 years of inspections across portfolio; deficiency patterns
- Quality metrics: Falls, hospitalizations, medication errors, infection rates
- Training programs: Onboarding, dementia care training, continuing education
- Clinical oversight: RN leadership, medical director relationships, care planning processes
- Safety culture: Incident reporting, root cause analysis, quality improvement initiatives
5. Financial Stability
- Portfolio financial performance: Average occupancy, NOI margins, cap rates achieved on sales
- Balance sheet strength: Sufficient working capital to cover 3-6 months of operations
- Lease performance: If NNN lease structure, verify rent payment history
- Insurance coverage: Adequate general liability, professional liability, workers' comp
- Vendor relationships: Payment history with key vendors (food service, pharmacy, maintenance)
6. Cultural Fit & Values Alignment
- Care philosophy: Resident-centered care, family engagement, quality of life focus
- Transparency: Willingness to share financial data, operational challenges, improvement areas
- Communication style: Responsiveness, proactive problem-solving, partnership mindset
- Long-term orientation: Commitment to multi-year relationship vs transactional approach
- Ethical standards: No history of fraud, abuse allegations, regulatory enforcement actions
Partnership Structure Options
Option 1: Triple-Net (NNN) Lease
Best for: Family offices seeking passive income with minimal operational involvement
- Structure: Operator leases property; pays fixed rent regardless of occupancy
- Family office role: Landlord; receives predictable lease payments
- Operator risk: All operational, staffing, and regulatory risks
- Lease rate: 7.0%-9.5% of purchase price (annual rent)
- Term: 15-20 years with renewal options
- Pros: Predictable cash flow; no operational risk; operator has skin in the game
- Cons: Lower returns; limited upside if property outperforms
Option 2: Joint Venture (Profit-Sharing)
Best for: Family offices seeking higher returns with moderate oversight
- Structure: Family office owns real estate; operator manages operations; profits split per partnership agreement
- Family office role: Property owner; active oversight of financial performance
- Operator compensation: Management fee (5-8% of revenues) + profit share (10-30% after preferred return)
- Preferred return: 8-12% to family office before profit split
- Pros: Higher returns; shared incentives; transparency into operations
- Cons: Requires active oversight; profit disputes if underperformance
Option 3: Management Agreement (Fee-for-Service)
Best for: Family offices with sophisticated oversight capabilities seeking maximum control and upside
- Structure: Family office owns both real estate and operating entity; operator manages for fee
- Management fee: 5-8% of gross revenues
- Termination rights: Family office can terminate operator with 60-90 days notice
- Pros: Maximum upside; full control; ability to change operators
- Cons: Requires active governance; operator has limited skin in the game; transition risk
Red Flags: Walk Away Indicators
- High management turnover: Frequent executive director or regional VP changes indicate cultural problems
- Survey deficiencies across portfolio: Pattern of serious compliance failures across multiple properties
- Litigation history: Multiple wrongful death, abuse/neglect, or employment claims
- Financial instability: Late rent payments, vendor disputes, insufficient working capital
- Poor online reviews: Consistent 1-2 star ratings, complaints about care quality or staff responsiveness
- Lack of transparency: Unwillingness to share financial data, operational metrics, or references
- Overpromising: Unrealistic occupancy projections or expense forecasts
Connect with Vetted Senior Housing Operators
Browse senior housing properties with established operator relationships on SeniorCRE™. Access operator profiles, performance history, and partnership structures.