ROI Calculator: Point Solutions vs All-in-One Platform
What this article explains:
- •Topic: ROI Calculator: Point Solutions vs All-in-One Platform
- Who this is for: Administrators, CFOs, and IT directors evaluating senior living & care technology investments
- Problems addressed: Fragmented systems, integration costs, duplicate data entry, training overhead, data inconsistency
- Systems involved: Point solutions comparison, all-in-one platforms, TCO analysis, ROI modeling
- Why this matters now: Operators using 5+ point solutions spend 60% more on technology than integrated platform users
Senior living & care operators face a critical technology decision: invest in multiple specialized point solutions or consolidate on an integrated all-in-one platform? The answer isn't just about features—it's about total cost of ownership, operational efficiency, and long-term scalability. This interactive guide helps you calculate the true ROI of platform consolidation.
The Hidden Cost of Fragmentation
Operators using 5+ point solutions spend 60% more on technology than those using integrated platforms. Beyond subscription costs, fragmented systems create data silos, duplicate data entry, integration failures, and training overhead that drain operational resources.
Interactive ROI Calculator
Calculate Your Potential Savings
1. The True Cost of Point Solutions
Point solutions appear cost-effective when evaluated individually. A standalone eMAR at $3/bed, scheduling software at $4/bed, and a compliance tool at $2/bed seems reasonable. But the total cost of ownership tells a different story.
Hidden Costs of Fragmentation
Integration Costs
Custom integrations between point solutions cost $5,000-$25,000 per connection. Maintaining these integrations as vendors update their systems adds $500-$2,000/month in IT overhead.
Duplicate Data Entry
Staff enter resident data into 4-6 separate systems. At 15 minutes per resident per system, a 100-bed community wastes 150+ staff hours monthly on duplicate data entry.
Training Overhead
Each point solution requires separate training programs, login credentials, and support contacts. Staff spend 40% more time in training with fragmented systems.
Data Inconsistency
When resident data lives in multiple systems, discrepancies create medication errors, billing mistakes, and compliance gaps. Error remediation costs $200-$500 per incident.
2. Integrated Platform Benefits
All-in-one platforms eliminate the integration tax while providing operational benefits that compound over time.
Single Source of Truth
Resident data entered once flows to all modules—clinical, billing, staffing, and compliance. Eliminates data discrepancies and duplicate entry.
Unified Analytics
Cross-module reporting reveals insights impossible with fragmented data: labor cost per occupied bed, clinical intervention correlation with falls, marketing ROI by referral source.
Simplified Training
One interface, one login, one support contact. Staff learn a consistent experience across all functions, reducing training time by 50% and support tickets by 60%.
Automated Workflows
Native integrations enable workflows impossible with point solutions: incident triggers care plan update, admission creates billing setup, discharge notifies all departments.
3. Total Cost of Ownership Comparison
| Cost Category | Point Solutions (5+) | All-in-One Platform |
|---|---|---|
| Software Subscriptions | $12-18/bed/month | $6-10/bed/month |
| Integration Maintenance | $1,500-3,000/month | $0 (native) |
| Staff Training Time | 40+ hours/new hire | 16-20 hours/new hire |
| Duplicate Data Entry | 150+ hours/month | 0 hours |
| Error Remediation | $2,000-5,000/month | $200-500/month |
| IT Support Overhead | 8-12 hours/week | 2-4 hours/week |
| Total Estimated Cost | $18-25/bed/month | $8-12/bed/month |
When Point Solutions Make Sense
Point solutions may still be appropriate for specialized functions not available in all-in-one platforms (niche billing requirements, specialized therapy documentation) or when existing vendor relationships provide exceptional value. Evaluate each use case individually.
4. Migration Considerations
Transitioning from point solutions to an integrated platform requires careful planning. Key migration considerations include:
- Data migration: Historical resident records, staff files, and financial data must transfer accurately
- Contract timing: Align point solution contract expirations to minimize overlap costs
- Phased rollout: Consider module-by-module implementation rather than big-bang approach
- Change management: Staff accustomed to familiar interfaces need adequate transition support
- Parallel operation: Plan for 30-60 days of parallel system operation during transition
Ready to Consolidate?
SeniorCRE provides a complete all-in-one platform for senior living & care operations—clinical, staffing, compliance, billing, and marketing in a single unified system. See how consolidation can transform your operations.